November 15, 2026
NYPD Estimates 500–600 Attendees and Closes Ridge Boulevard as Community Demands Landmark Protection for Historic 7.5-Acre Campus; Councilwoman Kayla Santosuosso Calls on Landmarks Preservation Commission to Act
Filmed and Edited by Jack Furtado
BAY RIDGE, BROOKLYN — Hundreds of people flooded Ridge Boulevard on Saturday, November 14, 2026, in an extraordinary demonstration of community support for the preservation of Visitation Academy & Monastery, the historic 7.5-acre property known as Monastery Square in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn.
The New York City Police Department estimated that 500 to 600 people attended the rally, with crowds stretching from sidewalk to sidewalk across Ridge Boulevard. The turnout was so substantial that NYPD officers closed the roadway to vehicular traffic to accommodate the gathering.
Organized by the Visitation Academy & Monastery Landmark Initiative, the rally brought together generations of alumnae, former faculty, Fathers' Club and Ladies' Auxiliary members, families, preservation advocates, and residents from across New York City and Long Island. Some alumnae traveled from as far away as Arizona to stand in solidarity with their former school.

Hundreds gather for the Landmark Visitation Rally
Photo Credit Visitation Academy & Monastery Landmark Initative
Their message was unmistakable: New York City's Landmarks Preservation Commission (LPC) must act to protect the historic buildings and grounds of Monastery Square before they are lost to redevelopment.
A Celebration of the Past and a Call to Protect the Future
The rally unfolded against the backdrop of Sacred Heart Chapel, where a professionally decorated 30-foot parade float, adorned in blue and white, served as the stage for the afternoon's speakers.
The St. Patrick Roman Catholic Church Pipes and Drums opened the program with a stirring performance of Amazing Grace, setting a solemn and reflective tone before the crowd erupted into cheers.
Charles Fiore, former president of Visitation Academy's Fathers' Club and an executive board member of the Landmark Initiative, welcomed the gathering.
"Today is a celebration of all the great times we had here and the great times ahead," Fiore declared.

Photo Credit Spencer Lee Gallop
A roll call followed, recognizing the community, former faculty, alumnae, Fathers' Club, and Ladies' Auxiliary. As each group was called, participants gathered beneath their respective banners, standing together to declare themselves present and accounted for at Visitation.
The symbolism was powerful: generations of people whose lives had been shaped by the Academy and the Sisters of the Visitation were returning once again, this time to defend the place that had brought them together.
Speakers included Fiore; Al Marciano, former Fathers' Club president; Joanne and Gerry Durney, former Ladies' Auxiliary and Fathers' Club presidents whose three daughters attended the Academy for a combined 17 years; New York City Councilwoman Kayla Santosuosso; Historic Districts Council Executive Director Frampton Tolbert; and Caroline Cardillo, an alumna and founder and chair of the Visitation Academy & Monastery Landmark Initiative.

Councilwoman Santosuosso addressed the crowd from the parade float
Photo Credit Spencer Lee Gallop
Councilwoman Santosuosso: "They Are Going to Hear Us Now"
Councilwoman Kayla Santosuosso delivered an impassioned address, sharply criticizing the assumption that redevelopment interests should outweigh the community's desire to preserve its historic institutions.
"They think this belongs to a developer and a developer should be able to do whatever they want," Santosuosso told the crowd.
"I met with the LPC chair and demanded this be calendared. They do not hear us. They have not heard us. And I am so happy that we are all gathered here today because they are going to hear us now."
Santosuosso rejected arguments that landmark designation would make meaningful use of the property impossible.
"I do not want to hear from the developer that there is nothing that can be done on this property if it is landmarked. This is seven acres of land. Seven acres of land with historic properties of enormous value to all of us."
She urged those involved in the property's future to recognize the permanent consequences of demolition.
"Do not be greedy. Heed the community's call. Understand that once this is gone, it cannot be brought back."
"Institutions like this are disappearing across the city because of developer greed. Greed should not win over a community's values. Greed should not dictate what happens to this institution and this property."
Her remarks drew sustained applause and cheers from the crowd.

Cardillo addressed the crowd from the parad float
Photo Credit Spencer Lee Gallop
"It Was Always Us. And It Will Be Us Again."
In the afternoon's keynote address, Caroline Cardillo, a Visitation Academy alumna and founder and chair of the Landmark Initiative, reflected on her childhood at the Academy, the extraordinary legacy of the Sisters of the Visitation of Holy Mary Brooklyn, and the generations of women and families who sustained the institution for more than a century.
"For 122 years, these grounds held a monastery, an academy, a blessed community of women devoted to faith, devoted to prayer, devoted to the education of their girls, and to service to this community," Cardillo said.
"Today, that influence is wider than our lake, that legacy is rooted deeper than the roots of the elephant tree, and the love they gave us, and the love that shines down on us today, rises higher than any wall ever could."
Cardillo emphasized that Visitation's history extends far beyond those who attended the Academy.
"This is a history that belongs to all of Bay Ridge, all of Brooklyn, all of New York City, all people of faith, all women. And that is why we gather here today. To demand that the Mayor of New York City and the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission protect 8902 Ridge Boulevard, Visitation Academy, the Monastery of the Sisters of the Visitation, and all the grounds of Monastery Square."
She traced more than 122 years of alumnae dedication to the Academy and Monastery, recalling the approximately $50,000 raised between 1904 and 1911 to construct Sacred Heart Chapel, the $40,000 raised between 1914 and 1922 to build the monastery's enclosure wall, and the more than $1 million contributed to the Caring for the Future Campaign during the 1990s.
"And it was many of us who gather here today, and those who cannot, but whom we hold in the silence of our hearts, who raised over one million dollars for the Caring for the Future Campaign in the 1990s," Cardillo said.
"It was always us. And it will be us again."
The crowd responded with cheers, repeatedly interrupting Cardillo's address with applause.

Historic District Council (HDC) Executive Director Frampton Tolbert addressed the crowd
Photo Credit Spencer Lee Gallop
"We Drew the Line Today for Bay Ridge"
Cardillo's remarks grew increasingly forceful as she addressed the potential demolition of the campus's historic buildings and the community's determination to prevent their loss.
"We drew the line today for Bay Ridge, for Brooklyn, for New York City, and we drew it in front of Visitation. They think they can come here and knock down our historic buildings and be met with silence."
A voice from the crowd shouted, "No, they can't!" as hundreds cheered in agreement.
"And this is a fight we are not giving up. This is a fight that begins today. And let it be clear that we will fight until the very end. Until we win."
Cardillo pointed to the extensive historical documentation already submitted to the Landmarks Preservation Commission and the hundreds gathered before her.
"They said they need research. We gave them 430 pages in a binder. They said they needed community support. We brought hundreds of people to Monastery Square."
She concluded with a direct message to City Hall and the Landmarks Preservation Commission:
"We are going to make sure that we are seen and we are heard. We are going to make sure that the halls of City Hall shake with our voices. Mr. Mayor, NYC LPC, we are here, and we are seen, and we will be heard."
The declaration was met with another wave of applause from the crowd.

Crowd gathered from sidewalk to sidewalk on Ridge Boulevard. NYPD had to close Ridge Boulevard.
Photo Credit Spencer Lee Gallop
Why Has Visitation Not Been Calendared?
The rally also brought renewed scrutiny to the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission's handling of earlier requests to evaluate the historic campus.
On May 9, 2024, the Historic Districts Council (HDC) submitted a Request for Evaluation (RFE) concerning Visitation. Just one week later, on May 16, 2024, LPC responded in correspondence signed by Kate Lemons McHale, acknowledging that the property's primary street-facing building portion might warrant landmark consideration.
The response stated:
"Primary street facing portion of the building may merit consideration as a landmark; and that further study is needed to determine the significance and conditions of the overall site."
More than two years later, the property has still not been calendared for landmark consideration.
On October 1, 2026, the Visitation Academy & Monastery Landmark Initiative submitted an extensive 430-page Request for Evaluation, documenting the site's architectural, educational, religious, social, and cultural significance, including its origins as the nineteenth-century Kings County Inebriates' Home.
Cardillo questioned why the Commission has not moved forward despite its earlier acknowledgment of potential landmark significance, particularly as the property faces a pending sale to a developer.
"We are aware of the LPC's May 2024 response to the Historic Districts Council, acknowledging that Visitation may merit landmark consideration. We are also aware of a June 2026 response by LPC to a community member stating the street facing portion of the site appears to merit consideration. But once again citing further study is needed. More than two years have passed. Our historic nineteenth-century Kings County Inebriates' Home and Visitation Academy campus now faces the possibility of demolition amid a pending sale to a developer. Yet on October 20, 2026, 19 days after our 430 page submission, the Commission voted to calendar the Coney Island Lighthouse, a federally owned structure located within the private, gated community of Sea Gate. We support the preservation of New York City's historic treasures, including the lighthouse. But we must ask: Why has Visitation, a site the Commission itself acknowledged may merit consideration more than two years ago, still not been calendared?"
The Initiative is calling on the Commission to explain why a property it previously identified as potentially meriting designation has not advanced to the next stage of consideration.
The group emphasizes that its request is not intended to prevent the sale of the property or prohibit all future development. Rather, it seeks individual landmark designation for the historic campus, including the Monastery, Academy, Sacred Heart Chapel, enclosure wall, and grounds, to ensure that any future development respects and preserves its irreplaceable historic character.
Honoring the Sisters Who Built a Legacy
Among the most moving visual tributes of the afternoon was an eight-foot-long banner displayed on the parade float featuring photographs of 13 deceased Sisters of the Visitation of Holy Mary.
To the right of the photographs appeared the biblical verse:
"I thank my God every time I remember you." — Philippians 1:3
The banner also carried the Initiative's slogan:
"Our Home. Our History. For All Time."

Caroline Cardillo and Adrienne Mountis-Bauer, Visitation Academy Class of 2000 alumnae, embrace at conclussion of rally.
Photo Credit: D. Mountis
The tribute honored generations of Sisters whose lives of prayer, education, and service helped shape the Academy and the surrounding Bay Ridge community.
An additional eight-foot-long banner hung along the fence outside Sacred Heart Chapel, where rally participants were invited to sign their names, leaving a visible record of the community's commitment to preserving Monastery Square.
A March Around Monastery Square
Following the speeches, the gathering transformed into a procession around the two square blocks of Monastery Square.
Led by the St. Patrick Roman Catholic Church Pipes and Drums performing Battle for Scotland, hundreds of participants marched together around the historic property, demonstrating the breadth of support for its preservation.
The blue-and-white parade float, the music of the pipes and drums, and the generations of families created a public demonstration of the community's enduring connection to Visitation.
A Movement Reaching Across Generations and State Lines
While the majority of rally participants came from New York City's five boroughs and Long Island, alumnae traveled from across the country, including Arizona, to attend.
Many others followed the events through the Landmark Initiative's social media accounts, which gained more than 100 followers during and immediately following the rally.
The response demonstrated Visitation's remarkable multigenerational reach. Online comments included memories shared by alumnae from the 1940s and 1950s, while one member of the alumnae community recalled that her mother belonged to the Academy's Class of 1916.
For generations of Brooklyn families, Visitation was more than a school. It was a place where mothers, daughters, grandmothers, and sisters shared a common history, often spanning decades.
A 160-Year History Worth Preserving
The Sisters of the Visitation established their presence in Brooklyn in 1855, bringing a tradition of prayer, education, and service that would shape generations of young women.
The present campus contains structures dating to the nineteenth century, including the former Kings County Inebriates' Home, constructed in 1869 and later adapted as the Monastery, and the 1888 building that became Visitation Academy.
The Sisters relocated to the Bay Ridge property in 1903, establishing a religious and educational community that would remain there for more than 120 years.
Sacred Heart Chapel, dedicated in 1913, and the historic enclosure wall, completed in 1922, reflect the extraordinary contributions of the Academy's alumnae and supporters.
The property also includes mature trees, historic landscape features, and a lake that has been part of the campus's identity for generations.
The Initiative maintains that the property's significance lies not in any single building, but in the interconnected architectural, educational, religious, and social history of the entire campus.

Among the days activities participants were asked to sign the Landmark Visitation banner.
Photo Credit Visitation Academy & Monastery Landmark Initative
"This Is Only the Beginning"
The Visitation Academy & Monastery Landmark Initiative says Saturday's rally marks the beginning of a new phase in its campaign to secure individual landmark designation for Monastery Square.
The organization plans to continue its outreach to elected officials, preservation organizations, community members, and the Landmarks Preservation Commission while expanding opportunities for public participation.
A community event for neighborhood children is already being planned for December, reflecting the Initiative's commitment to introducing younger generations to the history and architectural significance of the property.
The organization invites the public to join its mailing list, follow its social media accounts, and participate in upcoming preservation activities.
The message from Saturday's rally was clear: the community has spoken, and it intends to be heard.
___________________________________
About the Visitation Academy & Monastery Landmark Initiative
The Visitation Academy & Monastery Landmark Initiative is a grassroots, community-led preservation effort founded by Visitation Academy alumna Caroline Cardillo in August 2026. The organization advocates for individual landmark designation of the historic Visitation Academy & Monastery campus in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, including its nineteenth-century buildings, Sacred Heart Chapel, enclosure wall, and historic grounds.
Through historical research, public education, community organizing, and advocacy, the Initiative seeks to preserve Monastery Square's architectural, religious, educational, and cultural legacy for future generations.
Website: LandmarkVisitation.com
Instagram: @LandmarkVisitation
Facebook: Landmark Visitation
Media Contact:Caroline Cardillo
Founder & ChairVisitation Academy & Monastery Landmark InitiativeContact@LandmarkVisitation.comLandmarkVisitation.com



















